Your Defective Medical Implant Lawyer

We’re here to help with your case.

Defective Medical Implant Device Attorney- Foley & Murphy

Foley & Murphy has handled a variety of defective medical implant claims. We have helped those injured by such defective implants and their families during a difficult period of medical treatment and recovery, coordinating insurance and other coverage benefits, dealing with loss of pay claims, issues a permanent impairment, and overall recovery.

Foley & Murphy has and is handling a variety of cases involving the recall of defective medical implants and devices. This includes cases in a number of different MDL proceedings throughout the United States involving defects with knee implants and with hip implants. Foley & Murphy is also representing women from Indiana and Michigan who have suffered injuries as a result of having had implanted vaginal mesh products which have proven defective and dangerous. A number of different manufacturers are involved, including Ethicon, Bard, Boston Scientific, American Medical, Coloplast, and others. These cases have been consolidated in MDL proceedings in the federal district court located in West Virginia.

Why Foley & Murphy?

1. Experience

Our Attorneys each have 30+ years in the practice of law.

2. Respect

Our Attorneys each have the highest rating from their peers.

3. Success

We have a history of successful jury trials and maximizing settlements.

4. Caring

We do not handle thousands of cases, but a select few; providing our clients with individualized attention assisted by a kind and caring staff.

FDA Approval Process

Before a medical implant, such as an artificial hip or knee or cardiac pacemaker, can be sold in the United States, the manufacturer must put the device through testing and trials. The manufacturer then must submit the implant to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for approval before the device can be distributed in the United States. At times, implant manufacturers push the FDA to approve a medical implant before the safety and efficacy of the implant have been adequately and fully tested. They do this for a variety of reasons, some good – to make the device available to patients who need it, and some bad – to get the device to market as soon as possible to start making a profit on its sale. Due to its limited resources, the FDA is unable to carefully test and screen all such devices or surgical tools. Sometimes, the FDA approves a new device or implant on the basis of its “substantial similarity” to an already existing device. Unfortunately, this can and has led to instances where a device has been approved and it is later discovered that the device is defective as failures occur after the device or implant has been placed in patients.

FDA Monitoring

Once the device has been placed on the market, the FDA continues to monitor it through post-marketing reports sent in by the manufacturer and through the MedWatch program, an FDA program that allows consumers and health care professionals to report serious side effects or defects, quality control issues and medical errors associated with the device.

Each year medical device makers offer for sale and use hundreds of medical devices, including joint replacement implants, such as knees, hips, and other joints; cosmetic implants, such as breast implants; and offer surgical instruments. Sometimes, unanticipated side effects or defects are discovered after the implant or device is approved for use. If the problem is serious enough, the FDA may issue a warning to the public. If the problem or defect is sufficiently dangerous, the FDA may decide that the risks of the device outweigh its benefits and issue a recall. When this occurs the patient should receive written notification of the recall and information on what to do in response to the defective product.

The FDA is supposed to be responsible for testing and approving each and every medical device for safety and efficacy. However, the truth is that the FDA is unable to carefully test and screen all such devices or surgical tools. In recent years, the approval process for medical devices has been accelerated as multi-national manufacturers motivated by the desire for profit have pushed harder and harder for fast device approval and less rigorous testing. Oftentimes, the FDA simply approves a new device, prosthesis, or implant on the basis of its “substantial similarity” to an already existing device.

Types of Implant Recalls and Claimed Defects

A wide variety of medical implants have either been recalled or challenged in litigation as being defective.

In September 2010, DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc. issued a recall of its ASR Hip Replacement Systems. This DePuy recall followed reports of a higher than acceptable failure rate often requiring another hip replacement surgery within 5 years. It is estimated that the DePuy ASR hip systems have been implanted in 93,000 patients. This hip recall only affects patients who had hip surgery after July 2003. Thousands of patients have already reported experiencing hip implant problems including: serious or ongoing pain, swelling and loosening or dislocation of the hip implant.

Davol Inc., the manufacturer of the Bard Composix Kugel Mesh Hernia Repair Patch, issued the first hernia patch recall in December 2005 after problems were detected with the “memory-recoil ring” which surrounds the device. Further related hernia patch products were recalled in 2007. The ring allows the hernia patch to be folded in half during surgery and then springs back into place when the device is placed at the spot of a hernia. In many cases, however, the memory recoil ring broke after it was implanted, which can lead to serious injury, including bowel perforation, bowel obstruction, and chronic enteric fistulas (abnormal connections between two sections of the intestines).

These are just two examples of defective medical implant recalls.

Contact Foley & Murphy

If you, a friend or family member has suffered injury due to a defective medical implant email us from our Contact page. You can also call us at 800-276-2525.

Foley & Murphy has handled numerous defective medical implant cases helping our clients and their families deal with the effects of such defective products.

Let's Discuss Your Case Today.



We want to hear from you and discuss how we can help. Remember, working with Foley & Murphy is like having a lawyer in your family.


  • We only get paid if we recover for you.

  • We have an entire team ready to work for you.

  • We want to help you in any way we can, including with medical bills and insurance issues.

We are ready to help in any of the following areas:

Serving communities in
Indiana and Michigan
for over 30 years.

Foley & Murphy handles and tries cases across Indiana and Michigan.
This includes working in the following counties, county seats, and cities:


10 Must-Know Bicycle Accident Statistics

Understanding bicycle statistics is paramount in identifying risks and promoting effective safety measures. Let’s look at 10 bicycle accident statistics!

7 Common Bicycle Accident Injuries

Understanding the most common bicycle accident injuries is essential for taking appropriate precautions and seeking timely treatment when needed.

How to File a Car Accident Lawsuit

In Indiana, you must prove the other party was at fault for the accident, and you must file your car accident lawsuit within the statute of limitations.

Guide to a Whiplash Injury Claim

If you need representation in your whiplash injury claim, the personal injury attorneys at Foley & Murphy will help you understand the claims process.

6 Tips to Navigating Semi-Truck Blind Spots

When you’re on the road, it is crucial to understand semi-truck blind spots and take necessary precautions to ensure your safety on the road.

Doug Retires, Foley & Small is Now Foley & Murphy

Foley & Small, a South Bend-based personal injury firm, has rebranded as Foley & Murphy following Doug Small’s retirement. Edward L. Murphy Jr. joins the firm.

What to Expect During a Lawyer Consultation

Let’s walk you through what to expect during a lawyer consultation, ensuring that you are prepared and informed on how to navigate the legal process.

8 Practical Tips for Ensuring Construction Site Safety 

Construction workers and project managers must understand the importance of following strict construction site safety protocols to prevent accidents.

Foley & Murphy
1002 E. Jefferson Blvd.
South Bend, IN 46617